Home Speak to a lawyer Meet a lawyer Flat fee services About Blog Judgements Careers Contact Us Snippet Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Legal Topics
Snippet Details

Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation for negligence of BSES

  • Date: 2021-01-21 13:29:47
  • Views: 18

In May 2017, the Petitioner's 23-year old son lost his life due to electrocution after he was exposed to live electric wire. According to the petitioner, the death of his son was totally attributable to the negligence of the respondents, Delhi government and BSES Rajdhani Power Limited (BSES RPL).

The petitioner was a housewife, suffering from acute anemia while her husband, a labourer, earned about Rs. 48000 per annum. It was stated that they had no other source of income and the petitioner was running from pillar to post in Delhi to get justice for their son.

The Delhi government responded that it had no role to play in the incident as it happened in the jurisdiction of the distribution licensee BSES RPL. Several objections were raised by BSES RPL to the claim of compensation, including the issue of maintainability of the petition after twelve years.

The present writ before the Supreme Court was a bundle of disputed questions of facts which required extensive evidence by the parties and could not be decided within the ambit of writ jurisdiction, it was inter alia argued. It was pointed out that the Petitioner had previously filed a suit for compensation and since the same had been withdrawn, no writ petition was maintainable for the same relief.

The Court recorded that: (a) In 2019, it had directed the Delhi government to place on record the report of the Electricity Inspector with respect to the incident of electrocution. (b) the police officer concerned was also directed to explain the steps taken pursuant to the petitioner's complaint. However, the record in question were said to have been destroyed in normal course, it noted.

In view of the post-mortem conducted at AIIMS Hospital, the Court stated that the cause of death of the petitioner's son was shock due to electrocution and all injuries were ante-mortem in nature.

Since, admittedly, BSES RPL was the distribution company of the area in question, the Court held that the principle of res ipsa loquitur will clearly apply.

"..facts speak for themselves and the principle of res ipsa loquitur will clearly apply in these facts.. A clear averment has been made in the petition that respondent No.2/BSES-RPL was guilty of negligence. A young boy has died after coming in contact with a live electric wire that has fallen on the road. In the counter affidavit vague and evasive denial has been made. Clearly based on the above facts and the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, it is clear that respondent No.2/BSES-RPL is guilty of negligence. The death of the deceased took place due to the negligence of respondent No.2," the judgment said.

The Bench also reiterated that it has the power to award compensation in appropriate cases under Article 226 jurisdiction. Considering that the deceased was doing his graduation from Indira Gandhi Open University, the Court stated that his earning should have been at least around the minimum wages and after graduation, he would have earned at least Rs 10,000 to Rs. 15,000 a month.

In view of the above, the Delhi High Court awarded Rs. 10 lakh compensation to the family of the deceased for the negligence by BSES Rajdhani in maintaining electric wires.



More like this



SC to consider PIL to include Legal field in the Covid-19 vaccination priority list

2021-02-16

On Tuesday, the SC agreed to hear a PIL for the addition of judges, lawyers and court staff to be included in the priority list for Covid-19 vaccination.

SC to consider PIL to include Legal field in the Covid-19 vaccination priority list

DNA Technology Regulation Bill, 2019.

2021-02-12

The DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 2019, aims to establish the identity of victims, offenders, undertrials, missing people, unknown dead people, suspects and undertrials. It proposes a DNA Regulatory Board to address concerns a

DNA Technology Regulation Bill, 2019.

HC discusses the invocation of arbitration clause if one party appoints arbitrator on 'ex-parte' basis.

2021-02-10

Justice Kameswar Rao will decide a petition wherein, on the arbitration clause' invocation, one of the parties appointed the sole arbitrator and did not receive confirmation from the other party.

HC discusses the invocation of arbitration clause if one party appoints arbitrator on 'ex-parte' basis.

Comedian Munawar Faruqui granted bail; SC says ‘FIR Vague.’

2021-02-08

On Friday, the SC granted bail to stand-up comedian Munawar Faruqui, stating that the procedure of the notice before his arrest was not followed correctly. The SC believed that the FIR was vague.

Comedian Munawar Faruqui granted bail; SC says ‘FIR Vague.’

Cryptocurrency Ban: India plans to introduce new law prohibiting all 'Private Cryptocurrencies.'

2021-02-04

The government at the Centre is planning to introduce a new law banning all private cryptocurrencies. However, the new law will allow certain exceptions to promote the underlying technology of cryptocurrency and its uses.

Cryptocurrency Ban: India plans to introduce new law prohibiting all 'Private Cryptocurrencies.'

SC stays Bombay HC Judgement of the interpretation of 'Sexual Assault' under the POCSO Act.

2021-02-01

The SC stayed the acquittal of the accused, wherein it was held that pressing of a minor girl's breasts without disrobing does not amount to "sexual assault" within the meaning of Section 8 of POCSO Act. Meanwhile, the NCPCR has asked the Maharashtra

SC stays Bombay HC Judgement of the interpretation of 'Sexual Assault' under the POCSO Act.

SC drops UP Govt's plea to stop HC from examining Love-Jihad Laws

2021-01-28

On Monday, the SC dismissed the UP government's plea seeking to prevent the Allahabad HC from investigating the state's controversial anti-conversion law and that no constitutional court should be "lightly" pursued.

SC drops UP Govt's plea to stop HC from examining Love-Jihad Laws

SC drops policy of excluding the reserved community from competing

2021-01-27

Under Article 32, two female nominees from reserved groups approached the SC opposing the appointment process undertaken in 2013 to fill the vacancies of constables in the UP Police. The SC dropped the policy that excluded the reserved community from

SC drops policy of excluding the reserved community from competing

Will non-payment of stamp duty, hold the contract's arbitration clause invalid?

2021-01-25

The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court has determined that non-payment of the stamp duty on a commercial contract will not invalidate the arbitration provision which forms part of that contract.

Will non-payment of stamp duty, hold the contract's arbitration clause invalid?

Supreme Court: Committee will proceed with or without protesting farmers.

2021-01-22

The Supreme Court stated that the panel members are the agricultural fields' brilliant minds, and no one is pressuring the farmers to come before the Committee against their will. The court said that Committee would move ahead with or without the pre

Supreme Court: Committee will proceed with or without protesting farmers.

Petitions filed by scholars against MPPSC dismissed by Madhya Pradesh HC.

2021-01-22

Madhya Pradesh HC dismissed the petitions of former scholars aspiring to become assistant professors and observed that petitioners had made a mistake while filling the form, hence they cannot be given the benefit of extra points.

Petitions filed by scholars against MPPSC dismissed by Madhya Pradesh HC.

SC Issues Notice on PILs For Uniform Law.

2021-01-22

A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court (SC) including CJI SA Bobde, J. AS Bopanna and J. V Ramasubramanian issued a notice on two Public Interest Litigations looking for consistency in the personal laws regulating divorce, maintenance and alimony f

SC Issues Notice on PILs For Uniform Law.

Supreme Court rejects Aadhaar review plea in 4:1 verdict.

2021-01-22

The Supreme Court on Wednesday, by a majority vote of 4:1, rejected a collection of petitions demanding a reversal of its 2018 judgement, which established the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar flagship scheme of the Centre.

Supreme Court rejects Aadhaar review plea in 4:1 verdict.

Protection granted to the creators of

2021-01-22

Bombay High Court issued anticipatory transit bail for three weeks to the Taandav series director, producer and authors, Amazon Prime India.

Protection granted to the creators of "Tandav" series.

Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation for negligence of BSES

2021-01-21

The Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation to the family of deceased for the negligence by BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. in maintaining electric wires in a Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation for negligence of BSES

Supreme Court : Notice issued in plea challenging AIBE Rules

2021-01-21

The Supreme Court issues notice in a Petition filed by a newly enrolled advocate challenging the AIBE Rules 2010 which mandates that an Advocate has to qualify the AIBE to practice law after enrolment.

Supreme Court : Notice issued in plea challenging AIBE Rules

Cyber data privacy in peril

2021-01-21

The recent controversy triggered by WhatsApp's move to unilaterally amend its privacy policy appears to have acted as a catalyst to shake Indian citizens out of complacency. Hopefully, the government comes up with an effective mechanism to deal with

Cyber data privacy in peril

SC: One-sided and unreasonable clauses constitutes an unfair trade practice.

2021-01-14

SC held that Developer cannot compel the buyers to be bound by the one-sided contractual terms in the Agreement as it is in violation of the Consumer Protection Act.

SC: One-sided and unreasonable clauses constitutes an unfair trade practice.

Allahabad HC: Compulsory Publication of Notice Under Sec 6 of Special Marriage Act is violative of Right to Privacy

2021-01-14

The Allahabad High Court has directed that while giving notice under Sec 5 of the Special Marriage Act, it shall be optional for the parties to make a request in writing to publish or not to publish a notice under Sec 6 of the Act.

Allahabad HC: Compulsory Publication of Notice Under Sec 6 of Special Marriage Act is violative of Right to Privacy

SC: An accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested.

2021-01-11

In an appeal, the SC held that an accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested on filing of charge-sheet by the police.

SC: An accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested.

SC: Legal rights of Parties cannot be thrown away

2021-01-11

While allowing the appeal arising out of Motor Accident Compensation Claim filed by heirs of a deceased couple, the SC observed that Advocates cannot throw away legal rights or enter into arrangements contrary to law.

SC: Legal rights of Parties cannot be thrown away

Happy Clients

Let us assist you in taking care of all your legal worries and immune you from legal risks.