Home Speak to a lawyer Meet a lawyer Flat fee services About Blog Judgements Careers Contact Us Snippet Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Legal Topics
Snippet Details

Child born in live-in relationship to be construed as a child born to married couple: Kerala HC.

  • Date: 2021-04-12 11:32:42
  • Views: 173

In a momentous ruling, the Kerala High Court has recognized that a child born in a live-in relationship would have to be treated as a child born to a married couple to surrender a child for adoption. Through a Bench of Justices, A Muhamed Mustaque and Dr Kauser Edappagath, the High Court was faced with a petition moved by a couple in a live-in relationship to reclaim their child who had been surrendered for adoption by the woman.

Pointing out that the woman had acknowledged her live-in partner as their child's biological father, the Bench ruled that the Child Welfare Committee's procedure while giving the child up for adoption was legally unsustainable. In its judgment, the Bench found that the procedure applicable to an unwed mother alone was followed.
 
The Court's judgment narrates that the woman, Anitha (name changed by Court to protect identity), gave her child up to a Child Welfare Committee (Committee), moved by anxiety when her partner John moved to another State and broke the relationship for a while. Their families opposed the couple's relationship since they belonged to different faiths.
 
During this interval, between making attempts to contact her partner, Anitha handed over her child to the Committee in May last year, executing a Deed of Surrender in June. The Court's judgment notes that Anitha's deed of surrender in no uncertain terms permitted the Committee to give the child adoption in February 2021. Treating Anitha as an unwed mother, the Committee proceeded to give the child in adoption to a couple under provisions of the Adoption Regulations, 2017 and Section 38 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (the Act).

After these developments, Anitha and John approached the High Court and moved a writ of habeas corpus, seeking their child's return.

The Government Pleader and counsel appearing for the Committee submitted that the child had already been given in adoption, and the Court opined that a writ of habeas would not lie since proceedings concluded under the Act "had legal colour". The Court, however, suo motu converted the proceedings to a revision petition, after which it was taken up by the Division Bench of Justices Mustaque and Dr Edappagath.

Noting that there were two situations for surrender, one whereby a married couple surrendered their child for adoption, and the second where an unwed woman gave her child up for adoption, the Court posed the question of whether a couple in a live-in relationship could be equated to a married couple for surrender.

The Court pointed out, "In the matter of married couple, the procedure ensures that both the parents execute a deed of surrender and; if the child born to a married couple and surrendered by one of the biological parents, and whereabouts of the other parent are not known, the child shall be treated as an abandoned child and procedure under Regulation 6 (of the Adoption Regulations) will have to be followed. This procedure mandates an inquiry to trace out the biological parents or the legal guardians."

Holding that the Act primarily sought to protect the child's welfare, the Bench underscored that the prime aim of the law is restoration and protection of the child in need of care and protection. The first right of restoration was with parents, then adoptive parents, foster parents, guardians and finally fit persons.

Finding that a live-in couple had the right of restoration, the Bench ruled that biological parents' parental right is a natural right not preconditioned by legal marriage's institutionalisation.
 
The Court, therefore, noted that both Anitha's and John's names were recorded in the birth certificate and that the child's surname also reflected the father's name.
Since the couple acknowledged their relationship, it was not for the Committee to inquire about the marriage's legal status, not being the competent authority to decide on such status, the Court held.

"Once it is found that the child is born to a couple, for all practical purposes of JJ Act, the inquiry must be initiated as though the child belonged to a married couple", the Bench ultimately underscored. Thus, any deed of surrender would have had to be signed by both parents, it was stated. Both parents did not sign, and the other parent's whereabouts are not known; the child was to have been treated as an abandoned child and steps taken to find out the whereabouts of the biological parents, the Court ruled.

In this respect, the Court recorded that no such procedure was adopted in this case. Admittedly, the procedure applicable to an unwed mother alone was followed, legally unsustainable as the child has to be treated as born to a married couple. Only after an inquiry about parents' whereabouts was fulfilled could the child be deemed fit for adoption.

Therefore, the Court ruled that the entire process followed in giving the child up for adoption was vitiated since only Anitha signed the surrender deed. Holding that the newly adoptive parents accrued no right since the process itself was illegal, the Court set aside the adoption and ordered that the child be restored to the couple.



More like this



Evidence Act- Provison 6 to Section 92 will not apply if the document is without ambiguity: SC

2021-05-13

The SC has held that the proviso 6 to Section 92 of the Evidence Act will not apply if a document is straightforward, without any ambiguity in meaning.

Evidence Act- Provison 6 to Section 92 will not apply if the document is without ambiguity: SC

Lawyer booked for the online post.

2021-05-13

After an inquiry, a case was registered under section 504 of IPC as per the magistrate's directions against an advocate regarding false propaganda of Covid-19 pandemic conditions on social media, and the Jangaon district court ordered the police to f

Lawyer booked for the online post.

Copyright Registration: Bombay HC shows the right way.

2021-05-06

Bombay HC sets the record straight through ruling that copyright registration is not mandatory for enforcement.

Copyright Registration: Bombay HC shows the right way.

Schools can't charge students for unused facilities: SC.

2021-05-04

The SC has held that private schools demanding fees from students for the activities and facilities not availed by them due to the lockdown amounts to 'profiteering' and 'commercialization'.

Schools can't charge students for unused facilities: SC.

In-Laws cannot be left out in bride suicidal cases: Madras HC

2021-04-28

The Madras HC held that in-laws should not be allowed to go scot-free in bride suicide cases just because they did not live with the bride.

In-Laws cannot be left out in bride suicidal cases: Madras HC

Indian Parties can choose a foreign seat for Arbitration: SC

2021-04-28

The SC held that parties to a contract who are Indian nationals or Companies incorporated in India could choose a forum for arbitration outside India.

Indian Parties can choose a foreign seat for Arbitration: SC

IRDAI imposes INR 51 Lakh penalty on four insurers

2021-04-22

Insurance regulator IRDAI has imposed a penalty of INR 51 lakh on four insurers, including SBI General Insurance Company, to violate certain norms related to motor insurance.

IRDAI imposes INR 51 Lakh penalty on four insurers

SC orders HCs to amend rules governing criminal trials to address delay,  deficiencies

2021-04-22

On Tuesday, the SC ordered HCs across the country to amend their rules governing criminal trials to incorporate the draft rules prepared by three SC-appointed Amici Curiae to address delays and deficiencies in criminal trials.

SC orders HCs to amend rules governing criminal trials to address delay, deficiencies

Child born in live-in relationship to be construed as a child born to married couple: Kerala HC.

2021-04-12

In a momentous ruling, the Kerala HC has recognized that a child born in a live-in relationship would have to be treated as a child born to a married couple to surrender a child for adoption.

Child born in live-in relationship to be construed as a child born to married couple: Kerala HC.

SC allows the deportation of Rohingyas to Myanmar as per the procedure prescribed

2021-04-09

The SC on Thursday refused to grant relief in a petition challenging the detention of Rohingya refugees in Jammu and the move to deport them back to their parent country Myanmar.

SC allows the deportation of Rohingyas to Myanmar as per the procedure prescribed

Mask is compulsory even if driving alone: Delhi HC.

2021-04-07

The Delhi HC said today that a mask is compulsory even if a person is driving alone in a car, terming any vehicle a "public place" where Covid rules apply.

Mask is compulsory even if driving alone: Delhi HC.

86% insolvency cases pending over 270 days

2021-04-07

Over 85% of the ongoing corporate insolvency cases have dragged beyond 270 days, which was the upper limit for finalizing the process.

86% insolvency cases pending over 270 days

The SC directs the former Police Commissioner to the HC for the CBI probe

2021-03-24

The Apex Court directs the former Police Commissioner to move the HC for the CBI probe against Anil Deshmukh.

The SC directs the former Police Commissioner to the HC for the CBI probe

SC holds that a cryptic telephonic message does not amount to an FIR

2021-03-24

SC observes that a telephonic message not distinctly specifying the offense is not an FIR.

SC holds that a cryptic telephonic message does not amount to an FIR

Advocates can only earn livelihood if they come into contact with people: SC

2021-03-19

The SC on Thursday orally observed that the concerns of the legal fraternity regarding priority for COVID-19 vaccination were genuine, which require consideration.

Advocates can only earn livelihood if they come into contact with people: SC

Court judgments should be in a language that can be understood by both lawyers and citizens: SC.

2021-03-18

A Bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah stated that the purpose of judgments is to convey the basis and reasons for its decision to lawyers and citizens who approach courts for remedy.

Court judgments should be in a language that can be understood by both lawyers and citizens: SC.

Parliament passes Arbitration & Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2021

2021-03-11

On Wednesday, Rajya Sabha passed the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2021, by voice vote. The Lok Sabha passed the Bill on February 12, 2201. The bill proposes to put an automatic stay on awards induced by fraud/corruption.

Parliament passes Arbitration & Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2021

Wife not husband's chattel, can't be forced to live with him: SC.

2021-03-04

SC observed that a woman is not a chattel to be forced to live with her husband, hearing a case where a man sought an order from the family court at Gorakhpur to his spouse to start living with him again.

Wife not husband's chattel, can't be forced to live with him: SC.

Digital filing of pleadings and documents should be encouraged: Delhi HC.

2021-03-04

Delhi HC stated that digital filing should be encouraged before all courts to capitalize upon the learning and experience derived during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Court had even directed that an amount of INR 2.52 crore be released from its budget.

Digital filing of pleadings and documents should be encouraged: Delhi HC.

Lawyer sent to jail for sending birthday wishes to judge.

2021-03-04

The Madhya Pradesh HC will hear a bail plea today that was filed by a jailed lawyer who had downloaded the judge's photo from her Facebook account and attached it to a birthday card sent by email.

Lawyer sent to jail for sending birthday wishes to judge.

Citing poor infra, SC seeks a legislative impact study on consumer law

2021-03-02

An SC bench, headed by Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, directed the government to place the said study before the court to indicate if social, economic and institutional impacts were taken into account before replacing the 1986 consumer protection 2019 l

Citing poor infra, SC seeks a legislative impact study on consumer law

Delhi High Court directs Centre to constitute a committee to determine if payment gateways can be reporting entity under PMLA, 2002

2021-03-02

Delhi High Court directs the Ministry of Finance to form a committee to determine whether payment gateway service providers can be a reporting entity under PMLA, 2002.

Delhi High Court directs Centre to constitute a committee to determine if payment gateways can be reporting entity under PMLA, 2002

Supreme Court dismisses petition challenging supremacy of Central Government over States in transferring IPS Cadres

2021-03-02

Supreme Court dismisses challenge to Rule 6(1) of the IPS Service Cadre Rules giving supremacy to Central Government over States in officers' transfer.

Supreme Court dismisses petition challenging supremacy of Central Government over States in transferring IPS Cadres

Car manufacturer not liable for the sale of a worn-out car by the dealer without the manufacturer's knowledge: Supreme Court

2021-03-01

The Supreme Court held that a car manufacturer could not be held liable for delivery of a defective car by the car dealer in the manufacturer's absence of knowledge.

Car manufacturer not liable for the sale of a worn-out car by the dealer without the manufacturer's knowledge: Supreme Court

SC to consider PIL to include Legal field in the Covid-19 vaccination priority list

2021-02-16

On Tuesday, the SC agreed to hear a PIL for the addition of judges, lawyers and court staff to be included in the priority list for Covid-19 vaccination.

SC to consider PIL to include Legal field in the Covid-19 vaccination priority list

DNA Technology Regulation Bill, 2019.

2021-02-12

The DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 2019, aims to establish the identity of victims, offenders, undertrials, missing people, unknown dead people, suspects and undertrials. It proposes a DNA Regulatory Board to address concerns a

DNA Technology Regulation Bill, 2019.

HC discusses the invocation of arbitration clause if one party appoints arbitrator on 'ex-parte' basis.

2021-02-10

Justice Kameswar Rao will decide a petition wherein, on the arbitration clause' invocation, one of the parties appointed the sole arbitrator and did not receive confirmation from the other party.

HC discusses the invocation of arbitration clause if one party appoints arbitrator on 'ex-parte' basis.

Comedian Munawar Faruqui granted bail; SC says ‘FIR Vague.’

2021-02-08

On Friday, the SC granted bail to stand-up comedian Munawar Faruqui, stating that the procedure of the notice before his arrest was not followed correctly. The SC believed that the FIR was vague.

Comedian Munawar Faruqui granted bail; SC says ‘FIR Vague.’

Cryptocurrency Ban: India plans to introduce new law prohibiting all 'Private Cryptocurrencies.'

2021-02-04

The government at the Centre is planning to introduce a new law banning all private cryptocurrencies. However, the new law will allow certain exceptions to promote the underlying technology of cryptocurrency and its uses.

Cryptocurrency Ban: India plans to introduce new law prohibiting all 'Private Cryptocurrencies.'

SC stays Bombay HC Judgement of the interpretation of 'Sexual Assault' under the POCSO Act.

2021-02-01

The SC stayed the acquittal of the accused, wherein it was held that pressing of a minor girl's breasts without disrobing does not amount to "sexual assault" within the meaning of Section 8 of POCSO Act. Meanwhile, the NCPCR has asked the Maharashtra

SC stays Bombay HC Judgement of the interpretation of 'Sexual Assault' under the POCSO Act.

SC drops UP Govt's plea to stop HC from examining Love-Jihad Laws

2021-01-28

On Monday, the SC dismissed the UP government's plea seeking to prevent the Allahabad HC from investigating the state's controversial anti-conversion law and that no constitutional court should be "lightly" pursued.

SC drops UP Govt's plea to stop HC from examining Love-Jihad Laws

SC drops policy of excluding the reserved community from competing

2021-01-27

Under Article 32, two female nominees from reserved groups approached the SC opposing the appointment process undertaken in 2013 to fill the vacancies of constables in the UP Police. The SC dropped the policy that excluded the reserved community from

SC drops policy of excluding the reserved community from competing

Will non-payment of stamp duty, hold the contract's arbitration clause invalid?

2021-01-25

The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court has determined that non-payment of the stamp duty on a commercial contract will not invalidate the arbitration provision which forms part of that contract.

Will non-payment of stamp duty, hold the contract's arbitration clause invalid?

Supreme Court: Committee will proceed with or without protesting farmers.

2021-01-22

The Supreme Court stated that the panel members are the agricultural fields' brilliant minds, and no one is pressuring the farmers to come before the Committee against their will. The court said that Committee would move ahead with or without the pre

Supreme Court: Committee will proceed with or without protesting farmers.

Petitions filed by scholars against MPPSC dismissed by Madhya Pradesh HC.

2021-01-22

Madhya Pradesh HC dismissed the petitions of former scholars aspiring to become assistant professors and observed that petitioners had made a mistake while filling the form, hence they cannot be given the benefit of extra points.

Petitions filed by scholars against MPPSC dismissed by Madhya Pradesh HC.

SC Issues Notice on PILs For Uniform Law.

2021-01-22

A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court (SC) including CJI SA Bobde, J. AS Bopanna and J. V Ramasubramanian issued a notice on two Public Interest Litigations looking for consistency in the personal laws regulating divorce, maintenance and alimony f

SC Issues Notice on PILs For Uniform Law.

Supreme Court rejects Aadhaar review plea in 4:1 verdict.

2021-01-22

The Supreme Court on Wednesday, by a majority vote of 4:1, rejected a collection of petitions demanding a reversal of its 2018 judgement, which established the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar flagship scheme of the Centre.

Supreme Court rejects Aadhaar review plea in 4:1 verdict.

Protection granted to the creators of

2021-01-22

Bombay High Court issued anticipatory transit bail for three weeks to the Taandav series director, producer and authors, Amazon Prime India.

Protection granted to the creators of "Tandav" series.

Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation for negligence of BSES

2021-01-21

The Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation to the family of deceased for the negligence by BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. in maintaining electric wires in a Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Delhi HC awarded 10 lakh compensation for negligence of BSES

Supreme Court : Notice issued in plea challenging AIBE Rules

2021-01-21

The Supreme Court issues notice in a Petition filed by a newly enrolled advocate challenging the AIBE Rules 2010 which mandates that an Advocate has to qualify the AIBE to practice law after enrolment.

Supreme Court : Notice issued in plea challenging AIBE Rules

Cyber data privacy in peril

2021-01-21

The recent controversy triggered by WhatsApp's move to unilaterally amend its privacy policy appears to have acted as a catalyst to shake Indian citizens out of complacency. Hopefully, the government comes up with an effective mechanism to deal with

Cyber data privacy in peril

SC: One-sided and unreasonable clauses constitutes an unfair trade practice.

2021-01-14

SC held that Developer cannot compel the buyers to be bound by the one-sided contractual terms in the Agreement as it is in violation of the Consumer Protection Act.

SC: One-sided and unreasonable clauses constitutes an unfair trade practice.

Allahabad HC: Compulsory Publication of Notice Under Sec 6 of Special Marriage Act is violative of Right to Privacy

2021-01-14

The Allahabad High Court has directed that while giving notice under Sec 5 of the Special Marriage Act, it shall be optional for the parties to make a request in writing to publish or not to publish a notice under Sec 6 of the Act.

Allahabad HC: Compulsory Publication of Notice Under Sec 6 of Special Marriage Act is violative of Right to Privacy

SC: An accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested.

2021-01-11

In an appeal, the SC held that an accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested on filing of charge-sheet by the police.

SC: An accused released on default bail cannot be re-arrested.

SC: Legal rights of Parties cannot be thrown away

2021-01-11

While allowing the appeal arising out of Motor Accident Compensation Claim filed by heirs of a deceased couple, the SC observed that Advocates cannot throw away legal rights or enter into arrangements contrary to law.

SC: Legal rights of Parties cannot be thrown away

Happy Clients

Let us assist you in taking care of all your legal worries and immune you from legal risks.